A mental health technician asks the nurse, How do psychiatrists determine which diagnosis to give a patient? Which of these responses by the nurse would be most accurate?
-
A
Psychiatrists use pre-established criteria from the APAs Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5).
-
B
Hospital policy dictates how psychiatrists diagnose mental disorders.
-
C
Psychiatrists assess the patient and identify diagnoses based on the patients unhealthy responses and contributing factors.
-
D
The American Medical Association identifies 10 diagnostic labels that psychiatrists can choose from.
The statement that matches what is being asked is Psychiatrists use pre-established criteria from the APAs Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). .
A. Psychiatrists use pre-established criteria from the APAs Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5).
This aligns with the concept that The DSM-5 is an organized manual describing mental disorders and the criteria that determine whether a given diagnosis is appropriate. It is published by the American Psychiatric Association (APA). It intends to facilitate accurate and reliable medical diagnosis and treatment. Item C describes nursing rather than medical diagnosis. Need: Psychosocial Integrity The underlying principle in the stem is best addressed by choosing the response that is both specific to the cue provided and consistent with evidence-informed psychiatric nursing practice. From a nursing standpoint, this selection guides assessment and interventions toward what is most clinically meaningful in the moment—risk reduction, safety, accurate appraisal, and support for adaptive coping.
B. Hospital policy dictates how psychiatrists diagnose mental disorders.
This could seem tempting if the idea in “Hospital policy dictates how psychiatrists diagnose mental disorders.” addresses a different mechanism or priority than the one emphasized by the stem The wording does not track the stem’s main cue, so selecting it would shift the nurse away from the most precise interpretation or priority.
C. Psychiatrists assess the patient and identify diagnoses based on the patients unhealthy responses and contributing factors.
This might be chosen when the idea in “Psychiatrists assess the patient and identify diagnoses based on the patients unhealthy responses and contributing factors.” addresses a different mechanism or priority than the one emphasized by the stem The wording does not track the stem’s main cue, so selecting it would shift the nurse away from the most precise interpretation or priority.
D. The American Medical Association identifies 10 diagnostic labels that psychiatrists can choose from.
This sounds reasonable when the idea in “The American Medical Association identifies 10 diagnostic labels that psychiatrists can choose from.” addresses a different mechanism or priority than the one emphasized by the stem The wording does not track the stem’s main cue, so selecting it would shift the nurse away from the most precise interpretation or priority.
Conclusion
The stem contains enough information to decide, provided the nurse avoids filling in missing details. The correct choice follows the tested concept exactly, while the other options require leaps that the scenario does not justify.